Forget Shopify! These Alternatives Can Save You $500/Mo
By MyWifeQuitHerJob Ecommerce Channel
Summary
## Key takeaways - **Shopify apps add up quickly**: While Shopify's base plan is $29/month, the average store uses 6-8 apps costing $66/month each, leading to $400-$500 monthly expenses, or at least $200 for lean operations. [00:51], [01:14] - **Shopify Payments has country limitations**: Shopify Payments is only available in 22 countries. If you're outside these regions, you're forced to use third-party processors and pay an extra 1-2% transaction fee on every sale. [01:38], [01:49] - **Shopify can shut down your store**: Shopify can flag stores for issues like price gouging or selling restricted items (adult products, firearms, chemicals) and shut them down without warning, impacting revenue and SEO. [02:46], [03:12] - **WooCommerce offers freedom and cost savings**: WooCommerce, built on WordPress, allows selling virtually anything without fear of shutdown and can be run for as little as $2.69/month, unlike Shopify's app-dependent costs. [04:08], [05:45] - **Shift4Shop can be entirely free**: If you're in the US and process at least $1,000/month via Shift4 Payments, the platform is free and includes enterprise-level features like unlimited products and built-in email marketing. [06:54], [07:14] - **BigCommerce excels with large catalogs**: BigCommerce handles unlimited product variants and options, making it ideal for businesses selling customizable items or clothing with many sizes and colors, unlike Shopify's limitations. [09:48], [10:02]
Topics Covered
- Does Shopify secretly profit from your business constraints?
- WooCommerce offers total ownership and flexibility at low cost.
- Shift4Shop: Enterprise power, zero fees, but with a catch.
- BigCommerce outclasses Shopify for scaling complex stores.
- Why simple website builders kill serious e-commerce growth.
Full Transcript
When it comes to selling online,
everyone and their mother will tell you
to use Shopify. But here's the truth.
Shopify is not the best e-commerce
platform for everyone. And in fact,
depending on what you sell and how you
run your business, Shopify could
actually be the worst choice that you
make. Now, I've run a 7-figure
e-commerce store for almost two decades
now, and I've used practically every
shopping cart out there with real money
on the line. And what I found is that
Shopify has some serious hidden
drawbacks that no one talks about.
Drawbacks that can your business
if you're not careful. So in this video,
I'm going to walk you through when
Shopify does not make sense. And the
three best alternatives that might
actually save you money, give you more
flexibility, and keep your business
under your control. All right, so first
let's start with when Shopify actually
does not make sense. On the surface,
Shopify looks cheap. Their lowest plan
is $29 a month, which sounds pretty
good. But here's the problem. Shopify is
bare bones out of the box. You're forced
to load up on apps and their app store
has over 12,000 apps. The average price
of each one is about $66 a month. And
the average Shopify store, they are
running 6 to8 apps, which means that
most stores are paying $400 to $500
every single month just in app fees.
Even the students in my class, and they
run lean, tell me that they spend around
$200 a month just on Shopify apps. So
that $29 plan you thought you signed up
for, it quickly turns into hundreds of
dollars every single month. Now, let's
talk about payment processing next.
Shopify has its own in-house gateway
called Shopify Payments. And the catch
is it is only supported in about 22
countries. And if you don't live in one
of those countries, you are forced to
use a third-party processor where
Shopify taxs on an extra 1 to 2%
transaction fee on every single sale.
Now, 1 or 2% might not sound like much,
but if you're doing six or seven figures
in revenue, that is thousands of dollars
out of your pocket every single year
just for the privilege of not living in
the right country. Now, here's a fun
fact. The majority of Shopify's revenue
does not actually come from
subscriptions. It comes from payment
processing. Last year, credit card
processing made up 73.5 of Shopify's
revenue. Subscriptions were only 26.5%.
And that tells you where their
priorities really lie. But here's the
worst part. You don't actually fully
control your store on Shopify. During
the pandemic, I had a good friend who
sold hand sanitizer. He'd been selling
it for years, totally legit. But when
COVID hit, his supplier raised prices.
So naturally, he had to raise prices,
too. Shopify, however, flagged him for
price gouging and shut his entire store
down overnight. He wasn't gouging
anyone. He was just passing on his
increased costs. But that didn't matter.
His store was gone, his income was gone,
and his SEO rankings got destroyed. It
doesn't stop there. Shopify is extremely
sensitive about what you can sell.
anything related to sex, adult products,
firearms, chemicals, even certain
supplements, they can pull your store
down without warning. And when it comes
to copyright or trademark issues, you're
guilty until proven innocent. I've had
friends get their stores taken down from
fake infringement claims filed by
competitors. And Shopify did not
investigate. They just shut the whole
site down, and it took weeks with
lawyers to get it back up while revenue
was lost in the meantime. So yeah,
Shopify makes sense if you want
something quick and easy, but if you
care about costs, flexibility, or
control over your own business, it can
actually be one of the worst platforms
you can choose. So Shopify has all these
downsides. What is the best alternative?
Let's talk about Woo Commerce first. Woo
Commerce is basically WordPress with an
e-commerce plug-in bolted on. And here's
the thing, WordPress powers over 40% of
the entire internet. So, you're building
on the biggest platform out there that
comes with some huge advantages over
Shopify. First off, there's freedom.
With Woo, you can sell literally
anything you want. Adult products,
firearms supplements chemicals stuff
that Shopify would never allow. No one's
going to shut your store down because
they don't like your product category.
And you actually own your own site. You
own your own data, and no platform can
just pull the plug overnight. Second is
cost. The Woo Commerce plug-in itself is
free, and much of the functionality you
need can be added with plugins that are
either free or a one-time purchase. Some
premium plugins do charge annual
renewals for ongoing updates and
support, but even then, the total bill
is usually far less than Shopify. Third
is SEO and content creation. This is
where Woo Commerce blows Shopify out of
the water. Shopify's blog is clunky.
Their URLs aren't SEO friendly, and
you're capped in what you can do.
WordPress, on the other hand, is the
best blogging platform in the world. If
you want to drive traffic with content,
whether that's blogging, long form
guides, or SEO, Woo Commerce is the best
choice, hands down. Now, there are
downsides. With Shopify, they take care
of everything. The hosting, the
security, the updates. But with Woo
Commerce, you are on your own. You've
got to get good hosting. You've got to
stay on top of plug-in updates. And
sometimes plugins conflict with each
other. And if you're not technical, you
might need a developer on call. And Woo
Commerce can run really slow if you
don't optimize it properly. But here's
the flip side. Woo Commerce can be
insanely cheap to run. My kids actually
run a printon-demand store over at
kidencharge.com and their entire store
cost them just $2.69 a month to keep
online. That is it. Woo can easily be
the cheapest way to run an online store
while still being featurerich and
powerful. And it's not just for
beginners. I have colleagues running
high seven figure stores on Woo Commerce
without any problems. Now that said, let
me just give you a word of warning. Woo
Commerce is not for everyone. You do
need to be techsavvy or at least a good
problem solver. Things are going to
break. Plugins will conflict and you're
going to need to troubleshoot. And if
you're not willing to deal with the
occasional headache, Woo might drive you
nuts. But if you value freedom,
flexibility, and total ownership, it is
one of the best options out there. By
the way, if you're interested in
starting your own profitable online
store, make sure you sign up for my free
6-day e-commerce miniourse below. It's
100% free and I guarantee you'll learn a
lot. Now, let's talk about another
Shopify alternative that almost no one
talks about, and that's Shift for Shop.
Shift for Shop used to be called 3D cart
and it's been around forever, but it
never gets the hype Shopify or Big
Commerce get. And honestly, that's a
shame because it actually gives you way
more for way less if you fit their
criteria. The biggest benefit is that
Shift for Shop can be 100% free. But
there is a catch. You must live in the
United States and you must process at
least $1,000 a month using their payment
gateway, Shift for Payments. If you
don't meet those requirements, it's not
free. But if you do, you basically get
an enterprise level platform without
paying a dime in subscription fees. And
this isn't some watered down plan
either. You get unlimited products,
unlimited staff accounts, a built-in
blog, SEO tools, loyalty programs, gift
registries, daily deals, an affiliate
program, and even free email marketing
baked right in. On Shopify, every single
one of those features would cost you
extra in the form of recurring app fees.
But on Shift For most of that is
included out of the box. Another big
difference is that Shift for Shop does
not nickel and dime you with transaction
fees. Shopify makes most of its money
off of payment processing. And if you're
not in one of the 22 countries where
Shopify payments is supported, they will
hit you with an extra 1 to 2% on every
single order. With Shift for Shop, you
can use whatever processor you want
without penalty. And if you stick with
Shift War payments, your monthly fee is
literally zero as long as you hit that
$1,000 threshold. SEO is another win.
Shopify locks you into their URL
structure, which isn't great for
rankings. Shoreshop lets you customize
URLs however you want. And I've seen
people migrate their stores over and
keep their exact same URLs so they don't
lose any Google rankings at all. Now,
there are downsides. The app ecosystem
is way smaller than Shopify's. If you
want cutting edge AI tools or niche
functionality, odds are that they're not
going to exist. The interface also feels
more dated, and because it's not as
widely used, you will not find nearly as
many developers or tutorials online. But
that said, for the right person, it is
fantastic. My daughter actually runs her
jewelry store on Shift for Shop, and she
loves it. It gives her all the features
she needs. The built-in email marketing
saves her a ton of money, and she
doesn't feel like she's being nickel and
dime the way most Shopify users are. So,
Shift for Shop isn't for everyone. Its
free plan is US only, and you need to be
processing at least $1,000 a month for
it to be free, but it can be one of the
cheapest and most complete Shopify
alternatives out there. All right, so
next, let's talk about Big Commerce. If
there's one platform that really goes
toe-to-toe with Shopify at the higher
end, it is Big Commerce. And in fact, in
a lot of ways, it fixes some of
Shopify's biggest pain points. The first
big difference is that you don't get
nickel and dimed with apps. Big Commerce
comes with a ton of functionality built
right in. Things like advanced
discounting, tiered pricing, buy 1 get
one free offers, repeat customer
discounts, all included out of the box.
On Shopify, you'd be paying for plugins
every single month just to get the same
features. Second is product flexibility.
Right now, Shopify limits you to three
options per product and 100 variants,
but Big Commerce does not have those
restrictions. Let's say you're selling
clothing with lots of sizes, colors, and
styles or customizable products that
would break Shopify's limits. Big
Commerce can handle it all. And then
third is payment processing. Shopify
penalizes you with a 1 to 2% transaction
fee if you use an outside processor. Big
Commerce does not do that. You can use
whoever you want. No extra fee, no lock
in, and that freedom alone can save you
thousands of dollars once you're at
scale. Another big plus is multi-
channelannel selling. Big Commerce lets
you manage your listings on Amazon,
eBay, Google Shopping, Facebook,
Instagram, even Pinterest, all from the
same backend, and your inventory syncs
automatically across channels. Shopify
makes you buy thirdparty apps for that
same functionality. Now, it's not all
perfect. Big Commerce's interface isn't
as slick or as simple as Shopify. And
Shopify wins on polish and ease of use.
And because Big Commerce packs in so
many features, the learning curve is
going to be steeper. Their app store is
also smaller than Shopify's. So if you
want the latest AI powered tools, you
may not find them there. But here's a
big one. Big Commerce charges you based
on revenue and not profit. And that's
fine if you're selling high margin
products. But if you're running a drop
shipping business with thin margins, the
fees can make up a large percentage of
your profit. And that is why Big
Commerce is usually not a good fit for
drop shippers. Now, that said, for
stores with bigger cataloges, for B2B
businesses that need things like
wholesale pricing, or for sellers who
want advanced discounting and multi-
channelannel built right in, BigCommerce
is a really strong alternative to
Shopify. It gives you enterprise level
features without forcing you into a
$2,000 a month Shopify Plus plan. Now,
next, let's talk about Wix, Squarespace,
and some of the other niche players out
there because I get asked about them a
lot. Now, these platforms are fine if
you're running a side hustle, a hobby
shop, or if you just want to sell a
couple of products here and there. Wix
and Squarespace are really website
builders first and e-commerce platform
second. They look beautiful out of the
box. They're super easy to set up and
they come with drag and drop editors
that anyone can use. But the problem is
that they just don't scale. And the real
limitation is the app ecosystem. Shopify
has over 12,000 apps. Woo Commerce has
tens of thousands of plugins and Big
Commerce has a growing marketplace. By
comparison, Wix and Squarespace have
very few integrations. If you want
advanced marketing, AI powered add-ons,
or serious e-commerce features, you're
going to be stuck because those
platforms don't have enough users to
attract developers. For example,
Squarespace doesn't even support Clavio,
which is the industry standard email
marketing provider. If you want to run
serious e-commerce email, Clavio is
non-negotiable, and that alone is a
dealbreaker for me. On top of that, Wix
and Squarespace aren't designed to
handle large cataloges or complex
product configurations. If you're
selling more than a handful of SKs or if
you need custom variants, it gets messy
fast. Now, there are some older or more
niche platforms like Open Cart, Press
Shop America
if you've got a dev team. But honestly,
most of these either feel outdated,
don't have the community support, or are
just too heavy duty for 99% of small
businesses. Magento is fantastic if
you're running a $und00 million store
with devs on staff. But if you're trying
to build a six or a seven figure store,
it is complete overkill. So the bottom
line is this. If you just want a pretty
site to sell a couple of products, Wixer
Squarespace might work. But if your goal
is to build a serious business you can
scale, you will outgrow those platforms
quickly. They're not bad platforms.
They're just not built for entrepreneurs
who build real brands. So here's the
bottom line. Shopify is popular and for
good reason. It's easy, it looks great,
and has a massive app store, but it's
not the best choice for everyone. If you
want freedom and the ability to sell
anything without worrying about being
shut down, Woo Commerce is the way to
go. If you want a platform that's
insanely cheap, but still loaded with
features right out of the box, Shift for
Shop can be a great fit. as long as
you're based in the US and meet the
payment requirements. And if you're
running a bigger catalog or if you need
advanced discounting and multi-
channelannel built right in, BigCommerce
is a strong alternative to Shopify. But
Wix, Squarespace, and the smaller
players, they're just not designed for
entrepreneurs who want to build serious
scalable businesses. They're fine for
hobbies or small side hustles, but you
will outgrow them quickly. At the end of
the day, the right platform depends on
your business model, your budget, and
how much control you want over your
store. And the important thing is to not
just follow the crowd and pick Shopify
because everyone else is doing it. Do
your homework, test drive the
alternatives, and pick the platform that
fits your needs the best. Now that you
understand your platform options, make
sure you watch this video here on all
the different e-commerce business models
you can choose from and their pros and
cons.
Loading video analysis...