How To Be A Better Reader
By Closed Stacks
Summary
## Key takeaways - **Know One Book Intimately**: It's better to know one book intimately than to know a hundred superficially, as Julian Morrow says in Donna Tartt's The Secret History. Quantity isn't always quality. [00:34], [00:41] - **Deliberate Practice Accelerates Comprehension**: Decades of research show that focusing on specific reading skills like summarizing, noticing text organization, or making inferences improves comprehension more quickly than undirected reading. This holds true for adults as well. [02:50], [03:05] - **Transform Notes for Memory**: Making notes is most effective for remembering when you transform the text, like writing a one-page summary, restating ideas in your own words, or posing questions, rather than copying sentences word-for-word. Passive underlining has a small effect unless followed by a brief note. [04:16], [04:32] - **Leverage Spacing Effect**: Spread reading across several sessions instead of cramming into one long session to take advantage of the spacing effect, where a little forgetting between sessions strengthens memory as your brain reconstructs ideas each time. [06:01], [06:11] - **Adapt to Text Type**: Different books demand different attention: track events and motivations in plot-heavy fiction, focus on language and symbolism in literary fiction, and examine structure and arguments in non-fiction. Notice the text type and let it shape your approach. [07:04], [07:47]
Topics Covered
- Read one book intimately
- Deliberate practice accelerates comprehension
- Transform notes for retention
- Spacing boosts memory via forgetting
- Adapt reading to text type
Full Transcript
In a recent video, I talked about how to read more books. But I want to shift the focus a little bit because I would argue that there's something even more
valuable to you as a reader and perhaps as a person, and that is your ability to read well. Quantity isn't always
read well. Quantity isn't always quality. And you could read for several
quality. And you could read for several hours a day every day, but that doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to understand or connect with the heart and
soul of what an author or a book is really saying. I'm reminded of Donna
really saying. I'm reminded of Donna Tart's novel, The Secret History. Uh,
one of the characters, Julian Morrow, he said something like, "It's better to know one book intimately than to know a hundred superficially." I believe in
hundred superficially." I believe in that, uh, at least in spirit. And I
believe that becoming a better reader is a worthwhile pursuit. So today I want to shift the focus from how you can read more to how you can read better. You
know, people have a lot of different ideas about what it means to be a good reader or a better reader. You know, for me, it has nothing to do with being able
to read faster. And a lot of people will also tell you that to be a good reader, you have to read the really hard and really challenging books. Now,
challenging yourself matters, of course.
Uh, and as you grow as a reader, you'll naturally gravitate toward, you know, more demanding books, but becoming a good reader usually happens by working with material that's just beyond your
current level. You know, challenging
current level. You know, challenging enough to stretch you a little bit, but not so difficult that comprehension becomes a problem. reading extremely
hard books tends to be what skilled readers can handle, you know, after they've developed the necessary vocabulary or or the the attention or the processing ability. You know, in
that sense, reading very difficult books is more often the outcome of having strong reading skills rather than the primary method for building them. So,
when you boil it down, being a good reader is primarily about three different things. It's about
different things. It's about understanding more. It's about
understanding more. It's about remembering more and then being able to do these two things flexibly across different kinds of texts.
Now, another thing that you'll often hear people say is that you can build reading comprehension skills just by reading lots of books. And there are grains of truth to that. The more you
read, the more vocabulary you absorb, uh the more familiar you become with how sentences and stories tend to work. But
there's a limit to how far just simple exposure will take you. You know, it helps, sure, but it helps slowly. And
that kind of undirected practice mostly improves comprehension in a sort of broad or general way. But one thing that can really accelerate your progress is deliberate focused practice. We have
decades of research showing that when you focus on specific reading skills, uh things like summarizing or uh noticing how a text is organized or, you know,
making inferences, uh your comprehension improves and it improves more quickly.
And this holds true for adults or more developed readers as well. So my first suggestion is not just that you practice, but that you practice in a way that'll help you isolate those cognitive
processes. Now, to help with this, for
processes. Now, to help with this, for most people, I would recommend How to Read a Book by Adler and Van Doran. Uh,
this is a classic. Uh, for me, it was assigned reading when I was an undergraduate, but honestly, I would recommend it for anyone, whether you're a student or a serious reader or or even
a casual reader. If you're interested in improving your reading comprehension, then this is a great resource. In a way, it it kind of reads like a manual for active and intentional reading. The main
gist of this is that reading isn't just one skill. It's really a set of uh
one skill. It's really a set of uh progressively deeper levels of cognitive processing. So they structure the whole
processing. So they structure the whole book around these levels. There's four
of them altogether. And uh each has its own goals and uh its own techniques. And
there's a lot here also for both fiction and non-fiction. It's a really fantastic
and non-fiction. It's a really fantastic resource. I can't recommend it enough.
resource. I can't recommend it enough.
You know, making notes is probably the most effective thing you can do for remembering what you read. However, it's
only going to help when you do something new with the information. Simply copying
over sentences, word for word, that's not really going to move the needle. You
need to uh transform the text in some way. For example, you could write a
way. For example, you could write a basic one-page summary for each chapter or or maybe for the whole story, you know, whenever you're finished. a really
small and simple thing to do, but memory strengthens when you have to reconstruct the story and the characters in your own mind. Uh, other things you could do is
mind. Uh, other things you could do is maybe restate an idea from the book in your own words or you could uh jot down a a quick reaction or you could pose questions about what you're reading. You
know, make inferences. You know, those moments of mental effort are what's going to make the story stick. And the
same is true for underlining and highlighting. I mean, don't get me
highlighting. I mean, don't get me wrong, I underline, too. There's nothing
wrong with that. But on its own, that kind of passive marking has a surprisingly small effect on long-term memory. So, if you do mark or highlight
memory. So, if you do mark or highlight something on a page, follow it up with a brief note in the margin or or even some kind of simple that you've designated in
advance to kind of note something that's meaningful, uh, an asterisk or a question mark. anything that leaves a
question mark. anything that leaves a breadcrumb trail for your mind to return to later. But keep it simple. You want
to later. But keep it simple. You want
to still enjoy reading without uh making it feel like homework. You're not making a full study guide. You you just want a visible record of your thinking. Now,
another thing that you can do uh that has really nothing to do with note-taking, but another thing that you can do is uh spread your reading out across several different sessions
instead of trying to cram it all into a single long session. And when you do this, you're taking advantage of what psychologists call the spacing effect.
Uh it sounds a little counterintuitive, but actually a little forgetting between sessions is actually good for memory because, you know, each time you return to the book, your brain has to
reconstruct the ideas. It has to reconstruct the characters and kind of rebuild the world. And that act of rebuilding is what makes the memory
stick. So, if you're like me and you
stick. So, if you're like me and you actually enjoy reading during these really long and uninterrupted sessions, uh try to take a break once in a while.
You know, get some air, make some coffee, make some tea, just spend a few moments reflecting on what you've read.
Uh even brief spaced out sessions create stronger, more durable understanding than one giant push.
You know, different types of books make different demands on your attention. Uh
you don't read a poem the same way that you read a mystery novel. And you
wouldn't read philosophy the same way you would say a memoir. And even within fiction, you know, a plot-driven thriller asks for something very different than say, you know, Tony
Morrison or Virginia Wolf. One of the easiest ways to start practicing this is simply to notice what kind of text you're reading and then let that shape your approach. For example, with uh
your approach. For example, with uh plotheavy fiction, you might focus on maybe tracking events or character motivations. You know, what do people
motivations. You know, what do people want? You know, what do they fear? What
want? You know, what do they fear? What
do they choose? With literary fiction, your attention might shift toward language or theme or symbolism. And then
with non-fiction, you might look for structure. How arguments are built, how
structure. How arguments are built, how evidence is organized, or what problem is the author trying to solve. I
mentioned how to read a book earlier.
Not only is this a great resource for the kind of focus practice I mentioned already, but it's also an excellent guide for helping you understand these different types of books. For example,
how to read practical books, how to read imaginative literature, reading stories, plays, and poems, how to read history, how to read science and mathematics, how to read philosophy, how to read social
science. This is a wonderful guide for
science. This is a wonderful guide for how to navigate all of those different kinds of books. I can't recommend it enough. And it's great because it does
enough. And it's great because it does get easier. You know, over time, your
get easier. You know, over time, your brain begins to recognize these patterns automatically. You know, when you
automatically. You know, when you encounter a dense passage, you'll naturally slow down. Or when you hit a familiar genre, you'll pick up cues more
quickly. When the writing gets abstract
quickly. When the writing gets abstract or or philosophical, you'll instinctively switch to a more critical or reflective mode. Ultimately, being a
flexible reader is about awareness. you
know, awareness of the text, awareness of your thinking, uh, an awareness of when to lean in and when to slow down, or maybe when to simply just let the
book just kind of wash over you. It's
not about reading harder books, you know, just for the sake of it. It's
about becoming a reader who can meet any book on its own terms, you know, and that's when reading becomes not only easier but richer and deeper and far
more rewarding.
Loading video analysis...