The Queer Origins of Muslim Hate for Dogs: A Prophet, a Gay Lover, and a Puppy
By Raymond Ibrahim
Summary
Topics Covered
- Muhammad Ordered Dog Genocide
- Puppy Blocked Gabriel's Visit
- Gabriel Impersonated Beautiful Dihya
- Dogs Barked at Secret Lover
- Preserve Muslim Dog Aversion
Full Transcript
What's the deal with Islam and dogs? If
you've been paying any attention, surely you've come to suspect that Muslims simply don't like what is otherwise known as man's best friend? I've already
written about this phenomena over the years. Article links in the description.
years. Article links in the description.
But just in case you don't know about what I'm talking about, here are a few news clippings. In May 2025, just a few
news clippings. In May 2025, just a few days ago, the Muslim owner of a dog rescue shelter in the UK called Savapaw was arrested after the remains of 37
dead dogs were found at his premises.
Apparently, his scam was to take in the pets of owners who could no longer keep them on the promise that he would rehome them for a fee. In January 2025, dogs were reported as being slaughtered all
throughout the streets of Morocco with an estimated 3 million set to be exterminated as part of that Muslim nation's preparations to host the 2030
World Cup in August of 2024. And in the words of Turkish journalist Uzul, the dog massacre law that the government of Turkey passed on July 30 is causing a
rampage of cruelty by evil people in Turkey. Municipalities are now hunting
Turkey. Municipalities are now hunting down and massacring stray dogs, sometimes including pets loved and cared for, found in the neighborhoods of their owners. Horrifying news is coming not
owners. Horrifying news is coming not only from municipalities, but also from private citizens. Those who hate dogs
private citizens. Those who hate dogs are poisoning, shooting, and even beheading dogs. Some are buried alive.
beheading dogs. Some are buried alive.
In November 2022, and in the words of another local journalist, the mayor of Hebrron, a Palestinian city, offered 20 shekels to anyone who kills a dog in his city. Palestinians took to the streets
city. Palestinians took to the streets torturing and killing dozens of dogs.
The report is accompanied by a picture of what appears to be Palestinians beating a dog with sticks. In July 2022, Iranian authorities raided dog shelters and slaughtered 1,700 dogs that were
taken in as strays. According to the report, heart-wrenching footage showed a volunteer crying as she held the dogs.
One can go on and on with similar stories and they're in my articles, but I think you get the point. In short, you may have heard that in Springfield, they're eating the dogs, but in the
Muslim world, they're exterminating them like vermin. Muslim hostility for dogs
like vermin. Muslim hostility for dogs has even reached and is causing problems in the West. Reports of Muslim cab and Uber drivers in the USA, Europe, Canada, and Australia refusing to pick up blind
passengers because they're accompanied by their seeing eye dogs are immensely common, especially in that bastion of diversity and multiculturalism, the United Kingdom. In the UK, signs
United Kingdom. In the UK, signs forbidding the presence of dogs are not uncommon in Muslim heavy regions. Okay,
so Muslim hate for dogs is a well doumented phenomenon. It's a very real
doumented phenomenon. It's a very real thing. But where does it come from? As
thing. But where does it come from? As
with all questions concerning what is and is not Islamic, we must turn to the religion's founder, Muhammad. It's no
secret that according to many authentic or sah hadiths, including the two most authentic of all, Sah Bkari and Sah Muslim, he demonized literally and
called for the killing of dogs. In the
words of Sah Muslim number 1572, quote, "Allah's messenger ordered us to kill dogs, and we carried out this order so thoroughly that we even killed the dog accompanying a woman from the desert. He
means the guard dog of an elderly widow." After this dog genocide went on
widow." After this dog genocide went on for some time, and mind you, this is before gunpowder, meaning the prophet's followers zealously killed all these dogs with knives, stones, through
strangulation drowning etc. After a while, Muhammad revised his command and limited the killings to just black dogs. What the Sah Muslim hadith
black dogs. What the Sah Muslim hadith continues, quote, "Then Allah's messenger forbade their killing, and he said, you should kill the jet black dog with two spots above the eyes, for it is
a devil. So far, so good. At least now
a devil. So far, so good. At least now we know where all the modern-day Muslim hostility for dogs comes from, the Muslim prophet." Now, what's
Muslim prophet." Now, what's interesting, however, is if we put on our detective hats and piece together all the reasons as to why Muhammad hated dogs. I direct your attention to exhibit
dogs. I direct your attention to exhibit A, another Sah hadith. According to it, Gabriel the angel made an appointment with Muhammad. The angel said he'd visit
with Muhammad. The angel said he'd visit Muhammad very late at a specific night.
Muhammad waited and waited, but Gabriel never showed up, leaving the messenger of Allah most frustrated. The canonical
hadith narrated by one of Muhammad's wives Aisha is also found in Sahhat Muslim depending on the version either number 21104 or 5244 and it goes as
follows. Keep in mind Aisha is narrating
follows. Keep in mind Aisha is narrating quote Gabriel made an appointment to meet the messenger of Allah but the hour came and he did not arrive. The prophet
had a staff in his hand and he threw it down out of frustration and said Allah and his messengers do not break their promises. Then looking around, he saw a
promises. Then looking around, he saw a small puppy beneath his bed. Ya, cried
he, "When did this dog enter?" "By
Allah," squeaked the scared little girl.
"I don't know." So he ordered the dog out. Then Gabriel came. And the
out. Then Gabriel came. And the
messenger of Allah said, "You promised me and I sat waiting for you, but you did not come." Gabriel replied, "It was the dog in your house that prevented me.
We do not enter a house that contains a dog."
dog." Okay, so according to this authentic hadith which Muslims accept, Gabriel made an appointment to meet with Muhammad at night. But for whatever
reason, the presence of a puppy prevented this almighty angel from entering Muhammad's abode. That for
starters is rather strange behavior for an angel. In the Bible, for instance,
an angel. In the Bible, for instance, angels don't seem to be so scared of animals. For example, when Satan tempted
animals. For example, when Satan tempted Jesus in the desert for 40 days, Jesus, we learn, was quote, with the wild animals and angels attended him. Mark
1:13. Nor did the presence of flocks of sheep and other unclean farm animals prevent angels, literally the heavenly hosts, from appearing and proclaiming Christ's birth in their midst. Luke
2:8:20. There are many other examples including from the Old Testament such as Balam's donkey which interacts with and recognizes the presence of an angel before the human does. That's numbers
22:21-35. So what is it that scared Gabriel from a puppy under Muhammad's bed? Could it be that the angel was
bed? Could it be that the angel was afraid the dog would start barking if he approached the house as dogs are want to do and therefore cause a scene waking neighbors up at such an ungodly hour?
Maybe if Gabriel wasn't Gabriel. And
here is where the plot thickens. Enter
Dea Al Kalbi, exhibit number two, a close companion of Muhammad and his junior by 22 years. Not only do early Islamic sources and hadith obsess over
this man's unparalleled beauty, Dea was the most gorgeous man I ever saw. Even
little Aisha once proclaimed, but apparently the angel Gabriel was in the habit of taking on the form of Dea during his nighttime rendevouses with Muhammad. Sound familiar? This comes out
Muhammad. Sound familiar? This comes out clearly in several authentic hadiths.
Thus, according to another Sah Muslim hadith number 601, one night while Muhammad was at the home of another of his wives, someone came a visiting late at night. Taking a peek, she said, quote,
night. Taking a peek, she said, quote, "By Allah, this is none other than Kelby." Verbatim, I'm quoting the hadith
Kelby." Verbatim, I'm quoting the hadith for you. When Muhammad returned, she
for you. When Muhammad returned, she inquired, "Oh messenger of Allah, who was that?" To which Muhammad replied,
was that?" To which Muhammad replied, "That was Gabriel, come bringing teachings of your religion."
Okay, so let's put it all together and read as it were between the lines. And
please keep in mind that as with Alzot, the tall naked black men who rode Muhammad during that other infamous night in the desert, these are not my deductions or conclusions. Rather, I am
once again sharing with you what is being said by ex-Muslims throughout the Arab world, their contentions against Islam. The claim has long been made that
Islam. The claim has long been made that as with al- zot, Muhammad had a homosexual relationship with albi, this most beautiful of men. But because
homosexuality was of course frowned upon by the Arabs of Muhammad's time, especially by anyone claiming to be a prophet of God, he and Dea had to meet secretly, often in the night. So they
came up with a plan. If anyone saw them together, Dea would pretend to be Gabriel on the notion that the apparently vain angel was desirous of taking on the handsome man's guys whenever manifesting in the flesh to
meet with Muhammad. Of course, this begs the question, why didn't Gabriel take on an independent and even more handsome form of a man? Why did he always choose the already pre-existing appearance of
Dea? Kind of makes you wonder, though,
Dea? Kind of makes you wonder, though, what a rather convenient excuse whenever Muhammad's wives saw Dea with the prophet late at night in their homes.
At any rate, now let's return to and apply all this information to Aisha's important hadith about that little puppy dog. You will recall that she said
dog. You will recall that she said Gabriel had made an appointment to meet Muhammad that night. However, no matter how long Muhammad waited, no angel appeared. Looking around, a visibly
appeared. Looking around, a visibly frustrated Muhammad is spied a little dog in his house, which he promptly ordered Aisha to kick out. Having done
so, Gabriel finally appeared, confirming that he refused to approach because a dog was in the house. The meaning, as many ex and highly disaffected Muslims insist, should be plain enough.
According to them, this late night visitation by Gabriel was by none other than De Albby. However, seeing that a dog had entered Muhammad's house, he refused to approach lest the dog start barking, thereby creating a scene in the
middle of the night, causing all the neighbors to wake up and come out, see what's going on. Once Muhammad became aware of all this, he already suspected the puppy was the reason for his angel's delay since he had it kicked out. And
because the prophet of Allah didn't want to encounter this problem ever again and maybe even in a rage to avenge himself on those pesky barking animals, he ordered the ritual slaying of all dogs
in Medina. How sad to think that this is
Medina. How sad to think that this is the reason that till this very day, nearly 14 centuries later, Muslims still hate and kill dogs. Without giving it any further thought, all that Muslims are taught is that angels won't enter
homes with dogs and that some dogs, such as black ones, are demonpossessed. So
they despise and as seen kill them. If
you don't believe me, consider the words of a fetwa on the highly respected Muslim website Islam Q&A. It concludes
by saying, quote, "We must ensure that Muslims continue to be averse to dogs even in the midst of what the non-Muslims are used to doing and what some Muslims have adopted of their
habits. And Allah knows best." In other
habits. And Allah knows best." In other words, Muslims living in the west might assimilate and ease their stance towards dogs and heaven forbid even start liking them. No, he's saying this fatwa. We
them. No, he's saying this fatwa. We
must make sure they remain averse to dogs. Perhaps the saddest point of all
dogs. Perhaps the saddest point of all is that because topics like this are politically incorrect and cannot be acknowledged in the west. The west
remains complicit in the abuse of dogs.
According to a report titled, quote, "US spends millions to train bomb sniffing dogs gifted to Arab countries that abuse them. Many of the nations that the US
them. Many of the nations that the US gifts these highly trained dogs, which include Bahrain, Lebanon, Egypt, Indonesia, Morocco, and Syria, have well doumented records of abusing and killing
dogs like Vernon. Before closing, I would be
Vernon. Before closing, I would be remiss if I did not point out that there is yet another interpretation behind Muhammad's animus for dogs, an even older and more diabolical one. According
to this rendition, Gabriel was indeed an angel, but a fallen angel, a demon, if not Satan himself. Hence why he feared and hated dogs who according to many world traditions including if not
especially Christian traditions are known to see and bark at evil spirits lurking in the night. Therefore he Satan possessed his minion Muhammad into killing and teaching Muslims to kill
man's best friend. The fact that Dea al Kalb's last name which signifies his tribe literally means the dog in a twisted way almost validates this interpretation. Anyway, now you know
interpretation. Anyway, now you know where Muslim animosity for dogs comes from.
Loading video analysis...